Shower vs Bath: Comparing the Pros and Cons for Your Bathroom Remodel

When it comes to bathroom remodelling, one of the most important decisions you'll need to make is whether to go for a shower or a bath. Both have their pros and cons, so it's essential to weigh them up before making your final decision. In this article, we'll compare bathrooms with showers to those with baths, highlighting the pluses and minuses of each option.


The shower is a popular choice for modern bathroom design. It is practical, efficient, and perfect for people who are always on the go. Here are some of the advantages and disadvantages of a shower:


Saves time: Taking a shower is much faster than taking a bath. If you have a busy schedule, a shower can save you a lot of time.

Water efficiency: Showers are generally more water-efficient than baths. A standard showerhead uses around 2.5 gallons of water per minute, while a bath can use up to 70 gallons of water.

Space-saving: Showers take up less space than baths, which is great for smaller bathrooms. You can also install a shower in a corner or a niche to save even more space.

Accessibility: Showers are easier to access than baths, making them ideal for people with mobility issues.

Modern design: Showers have a sleek and modern look that can give your bathroom a contemporary feel.


Limited relaxation: Showers are not as relaxing as baths. You can't soak in a shower, and the water pressure can be too intense for some people.

Limited versatility: Showers are not as versatile as baths. You can't add bubbles, salts, or oils to a shower, which limits your relaxation options.

Limited luxury: Showers lack the luxury and indulgence of a bath. You can't light candles, play music, or enjoy a glass of wine in a shower.


Baths are a classic and luxurious choice for bathroom design. They are perfect for people who love to relax and indulge in self-care. Here are some of the advantages and disadvantages of a bath:


Relaxation: Baths are incredibly relaxing. You can soak in warm water and add bubble bath, salts, or oils to create a spa-like experience.

Versatility: Baths are versatile. You can add different ingredients to create different relaxation experiences.

Luxury: Baths are luxurious. You can light candles, play music, or enjoy a glass of wine while soaking in a bath.

Soothing: Baths are great for soothing sore muscles, relieving stress, and promoting sleep.

Increased home value: Adding a bathtub can increase the value of your home, making it a great investment.


Time-consuming: Baths take longer to fill than showers, which can be a downside if you're in a hurry.

Water waste: Baths use more water than showers, which can be wasteful if you're trying to conserve water.

Space-consuming: Baths take up more space than showers, which can be a problem if you have a small bathroom.

Accessibility: Baths can be difficult to access for people with mobility issues.

Outdated design: Some people view baths as outdated, which can be a problem if you're trying to achieve a modern bathroom design.

When it comes to choosing the best option for your home, there are a number of factors to consider beyond just the obvious features and benefits. Before making a decision, it's important to take a step back and think about what's most important to you and your household.

Size Matters: Small Bathroom Remodel

If you have a small bathroom, it's essential to choose a remodelling option that maximizes space while still maintaining functionality. This is where showers have an advantage. Showers take up less space than baths, making them an excellent option for small bathroom remodelling. With a shower, you can have a more open layout, giving the illusion of a larger space. You can also opt for a corner shower or a shower stall to save even more space. Additionally, showers can be installed without the need for a separate enclosure, unlike baths that require walls around them to contain water.

Bathroom Remodel Cost

Cost is a crucial factor to consider when remodelling your bathroom. Showers are generally less expensive to install than baths. According to Remodeling Magazine's Cost vs. Value report, the average cost of a mid-range bathroom remodel that includes a shower is around $19,000. In contrast, a mid-range bathroom remodel that includes a bath costs an average of $22,000. However, the cost of your remodel greatly depends on several factors, such as the materials you choose, the extent of the remodelling, the location of your home, size of your bathroom and few more.

Comfort and Relaxation

When it comes to comfort and relaxation, baths have the upper hand. There's nothing quite like sinking into a warm bath after a long day. Baths are also great for soaking sore muscles and joints. They offer a sense of luxury and indulgence that showers cannot match. However, baths take longer to fill up and require more water than showers, which can be a concern if you're trying to conserve water.

Accessibility and Safety

If accessibility is a concern, showers are the better option. Showers are much easier to access than baths, especially for people with mobility issues. They also have less risk of slips and falls, making them a safer option for older adults and children. Showers can also be equipped with grab bars and non-slip surfaces to make them even safer. Baths, on the other hand, require stepping over a high wall, which can be difficult for people with limited mobility.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Cleaning and maintenance are also essential considerations when choosing between showers and baths. Showers are generally easier to clean, especially if you choose a stall with fewer surfaces for dirt and grime to accumulate. Baths require more cleaning, especially around the edges and corners where dirt and soap scum can build up. Maintenance is also a consideration. Showers require less maintenance, but the grout and caulking may need to be replaced periodically. Baths, on the other hand, can develop cracks or leaks that require repairs.

Aesthetics and Resale Value

The aesthetic appeal of your bathroom is an essential consideration, especially if you plan to sell your home in the future. Showers are generally considered more modern and contemporary, while baths have a more traditional feel. If you have a small bathroom, a shower can make the space look more open and airy. However, if you have a large bathroom, a bath can add an element of luxury and elegance. Additionally, if you plan to sell your home, having a bath can increase the resale value, as many homebuyers prefer homes with a bathtub.

In conclusion, whether you choose a shower or a bath for your bathroom remodel depends on your personal preferences, lifestyle, and budget. Showers are practical, water-efficient, and space-saving, making them a great option for small bathrooms. Baths, on the other hand, offer a luxurious and relaxing experience but can be more expensive and take up more space. When making your decision, consider factors such as the size of your bathroom, your accessibility needs, and your desire for comfort and relaxation. Regardless of your choice, both options can add value to your home and enhance your overall bathroom experience.

Our Bathroom Renovation Services

At our company, we specialize in providing top-notch bathroom renovation and remodeling services to our clients. Our team of experienced professionals works closely with you to understand your needs and preferences, and create a custom design that meets your specific requirements. We offer a wide range of services, including plumbing, electrical work, flooring, cabinetry, lighting, and more, to ensure that every aspect of your bathroom renovation is taken care of.

With our attention to detail and commitment to quality, you can trust us to deliver a functional and beautiful bathroom that exceeds your expectations. We use only the highest quality materials and fixtures, and our team is dedicated to providing exceptional craftsmanship and customer service.

Whether you want to create a spa-like atmosphere, update your fixtures, or add more storage space, we can help you achieve your bathroom renovation goals. Contact us today to schedule a consultation and start transforming your bathroom into the functional and stylish space you deserve.

We are a professional home renovation company based in Westmont, IL, that offers top-notch house renovation services in Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Indiana, tailored to meet every client's needs.

Ready to Upgrade Your Bathroom? Contact Us Today to Schedule a Consultation and Transform Your Space!

Get a quote from us

Related News

View All
August 17, 2023

Solutions for a Small Bedroom

August 2, 2023

Inspiring Airbnb's around the world

July 12, 2023

Are you planning a home? An interior designer revealed 5 mistakes that 'eat up' the entire space.

June 30, 2023

Color in Interior Design: How to Choose the Right Color for the Kitchen Space?

June 16, 2023

Transforming Small Spaces: Creative Ideas for Maximizing Space in Your Home.

May 26, 2023

Open Concept Living: Embrace Space and Connectivity

May 12, 2023

Renovating Your Home with a Professional Contractor

May 5, 2023

Home Design Trends for 2023

April 27, 2023

Maximize Your Kitchen's Potential: Key Reasons to Invest in a Remodel

April 3, 2023
Bathroom & Basement

Transform Your Home and Daily Life with a Functional Bathroom

Get a quote

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Michigan Builder listened to my needs for the bathroom renovation, addressed issues, and completed the project within the estimated timeframe.
Larry, home owner in illinois
We all took shower in the new bathroom and it is spectacular. Draining is perfect, everything that you did works like a charm. Thank you!
OLGA, home owner in illinois
I recently had my kitchen completely renovated and remodeled by Michigan Builder and I must say, the transformation is amazing!
Ricky, home owner in wisconsin